Physics · Book 3 · Bachelor Year 1

University Physics — Year 1

University Physics — Year 1 · Bachelor Year 1

19Systems of Points; Introduction to Rigid Bodies

A diver leaves the board, tucks, somersaults twice and straightens out; through all of it one point of her body — her center of mass — traces the same plain parabola a stone would. A yo-yo dropped from the hand takes three times longer to reach the end of its string than a stone would, and arrives spinning at two thousand turns a minute. A solid sphere beats a hollow one down any incline, whatever their sizes or masses. The mechanics of a single point, carried through the previous chapters, extends to systems of many points — and to the rigid bodies of everyday life — through a handful of theorems: the center of mass moves as a point, energy and angular momentum split into a center-of-mass part and a part “around” it, and a body turning about a fixed axis is a one-degree-of-freedom system governed by its moment of inertia.

19.1 Center of mass and momentum

Definition 19.1 (Center of mass; momentum of a system)

For particles of masses mim_i at MiM_i, total mass M=miM = \sum m_i, the center of mass (barycenter) GG is defined by

imiGMi=0,i.e.OG=1MimiOMi\sum_i m_i\,\vect{GM_i} = \vect 0, \qquad\text{i.e.}\qquad \vect{OG} = \frac{1}{M}\sum_i m_i\,\vect{OM_i}

for any origin OO. The momentum of the system is P=imivi=MvG\vect P = \sum_i m_i\vect v_i = M\vect v_G.

Theorem 19.2 (Theorem of the center of mass)

In an inertial frame,

MaG= ⁣dP ⁣dt=Fext:M\,\vect a_G = \frac{\dd\vect P}{\dd t} = \sum\vect F_{\mathrm{ext}} :

the center of mass moves as a point particle of mass MM subject to the resultant of the external forces alone. For a closed system with no external force, P\vect P is conserved and GG moves uniformly.

Proof. Sum Newton’s second law over the particles; the internal forces cancel in action–reaction pairs; miai=MaG\sum m_i\vect a_i = M\vect a_G by differentiating the definition of GG twice.

Example 19.3 (Diver, recoil, collision)

The diver’s GG follows a parabola under her weight alone, however she twists — her muscles are internal forces. A rifle of 4.0kg4.0\,\mathrm{kg} firing a 10g10\,\mathrm{g} bullet at 800m/s800\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}: P=0\vect P = \vect 0 before and after, so the rifle recoils at 2.0m/s2.0\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}. Two cars, 1000kg1000\,\mathrm{kg} at 20m/s20\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s} and 1500kg1500\,\mathrm{kg} at rest, that lock together: v=20000/2500=8.0m/sv = 20000/2500 = 8.0\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s} — momentum conserved, while 60%60\% of the kinetic energy has gone into crumpled metal and heat. Momentum is conserved in every collision; kinetic energy only in elastic ones (Exercise 19.12).

19.2 Koenig’s theorems

Definition 19.4 (Barycentric frame)

The barycentric frame R\mathcal R^* has its origin at GG and is in translation with respect to the inertial frame R\mathcal R (its axes keep fixed directions). Quantities measured in it are starred: vi=vivG\vect v_i^* = \vect v_i - \vect v_G, and mivi=0\sum m_i\vect v_i^* = \vect 0.

Theorem 19.5 (Koenig’s theorems)

The angular momentum about a point OO and the kinetic energy of a system split into the contribution of its center of mass, carrying the whole mass, and the contributions in the barycentric frame:

LO=OGMvG+L,Ek=12MvG2+Ek,\vect L_O = \vect{OG}\wedge M\vect v_G + \vect L^*, \qquad E_k = \tfrac12 Mv_G^2 + E_k^*,

where L=GMimivi\vect L^* = \sum\vect{GM_i}\wedge m_i\vect v_i^* and Ek=12mivi2E_k^* = \sum\tfrac12 m_iv_i^{*2} do not depend on the frame’s origin.

Proof. OMi=OG+GMi\vect{OM_i} = \vect{OG} + \vect{GM_i} and vi=vG+vi\vect v_i = \vect v_G + \vect v_i^*; expand OMimivi\sum\vect{OM_i}\wedge m_i\vect v_i and 12mivi2\sum\tfrac12 m_iv_i^2: the cross terms contain miGMi=0\sum m_i\vect{GM_i} = \vect 0 or mivi=0\sum m_i\vect v_i^* = \vect 0 and vanish.

Example 19.6 (A rolling wheel)

A wheel of mass MM, radius RR, moment of inertia JJ about its axle, rolling without slipping at speed vv: the contact point is at rest, so ω=v/R\omega = v/R, and Ek=12Mv2+12Jω2=12Mv2(1+J/MR2)E_k = \tfrac12 Mv^2 + \tfrac12 J\omega^2 = \tfrac12 Mv^2(1 + J/MR^2) — three quarters of Mv2Mv^2 for a uniform disk (J=12MR2J = \tfrac12 MR^2), Mv2Mv^2 for a hoop. The second term is why a bicycle’s wheels are made light: their rotation costs energy that the frame’s mass does not.

19.3 The two-body problem

Proposition 19.7 (Reduced mass)

Two particles interacting only with each other (force F\vect F on m2m_2 from m1m_1, F-\vect F on m1m_1): GG moves uniformly, and the relative position r=M1M2\vect r = \vect{M_1M_2} obeys

μ ⁣d2r ⁣dt2=F,μ=m1m2m1+m2,\mu\,\frac{\dd^2\vect r}{\dd t^2} = \vect F, \qquad \mu = \frac{m_1m_2}{m_1 + m_2},

the equation of a single fictitious particle of reduced mass μ\mu moving under F\vect F about a fixed center. In R\mathcal R^*, Ek=12μr˙2E_k^* = \tfrac12\mu\dot{\vect r}^2 and L=rμr˙\vect L^* = \vect r\wedge\mu\dot{\vect r}.

Proof. r¨=a2a1=F/m2+F/m1=F(m1+m2)/m1m2\ddot{\vect r} = \vect a_2 - \vect a_1 = \vect F/m_2 + \vect F/m_1 = \vect F(m_1 + m_2)/m_1m_2. In R\mathcal R^*, GM2=m1r/(m1+m2)\vect{GM_2} = m_1\vect r/(m_1 + m_2) and GM1=m2r/(m1+m2)\vect{GM_1} = -m_2\vect r/(m_1 + m_2); substitute into EkE_k^* and L\vect L^*.

Example 19.8 (When the center moves too)

In Chapter 16 the Sun was fixed: exact only in the limit mMm \ll M; in general Kepler’s third law reads T2=4π2a3/G(M+m)T^2 = 4\pi^2a^3/G(M + m). For the vibrating HCl molecule of Problem 13.1, the mass that oscillates in the well is μ=mHmCl/(mH+mCl)=0.972mH\mu = m_Hm_{Cl}/(m_H + m_{Cl}) = 0.972\,m_H, which raises the frequency by 1.4%1.4\%; for the hydrogen atom, the electron’s μ\mu differs from mem_e by one part in 18361836 — measurable in the spectrum.

19.4 Rigid body rotating about a fixed axis

Definition 19.9 (Solid; rotation about a fixed axis)

A rigid body (solid) is a system whose points keep fixed mutual distances. If it turns about an axis Δ\Delta fixed in the frame, every point describes a circle centered on Δ\Delta at the same angular velocity ω=θ˙\omega = \dot\theta; a point at distance rir_i from the axis has speed riωr_i\omega.

Proposition 19.10 (Moment of inertia; angular momentum; kinetic energy)

With the moment of inertia JΔ=miri2J_\Delta = \sum m_ir_i^2 (an integral r2 ⁣dm\int r^2\,\dd m for a continuous body):

LΔ=JΔω,Ek=12JΔω2.L_\Delta = J_\Delta\,\omega, \qquad E_k = \tfrac12 J_\Delta\omega^2 .

Standard values (mass MM): thin ring or hollow cylinder about its axis, MR2MR^2; uniform disk or solid cylinder, 12MR2\tfrac12 MR^2; thin rod of length LL about its center, 112ML2\tfrac{1}{12}ML^2, about one end, 13ML2\tfrac13 ML^2; solid sphere about a diameter, 25MR2\tfrac25 MR^2. Huygens’ theorem: about an axis Δ\Delta parallel to an axis ΔG\Delta_G through GG at distance dd, JΔ=JΔG+Md2J_\Delta = J_{\Delta_G} + Md^2.

Proof. LΔL_\Delta and EkE_k: Proposition 15.9. Rod about its end: 0Lx2(M/L) ⁣dx=ML2/3\int_0^L x^2(M/L)\,\dd x = ML^2/3; about the center, L/2L/2x2(M/L) ⁣dx=ML2/12\int_{-L/2}^{L/2} x^2(M/L)\dd x = ML^2/12. Disk: ring of radius rr, width  ⁣dr\dd r, mass (2Mr/R2) ⁣dr(2Mr/R^2)\dd r: 0Rr2(2Mr/R2) ⁣dr=MR2/2\int_0^R r^2(2Mr/R^2)\dd r = MR^2/2; the ring and the sphere are admitted (the sphere needs a double integral). Huygens: with ri2=GMi+d2=rG,i2+d2+2dGMir_i^2 = \abs{\vect{GM_i}_\perp + \vect d}^2 = r_{G,i}^2 + d^2 + 2\vect d\cdot \vect{GM_i}_\perp, the cross term sums to zero by definition of GG.

Left: the moment of inertia of a disk, summed ring by ring. Right: Huygens’ theorem — about an axis through the rim of a disk, parallel to the axis through its center, J = 1/2 MR2 + MR2.
Left: the moment of inertia of a disk, summed ring by ring. Right: Huygens’ theorem — about an axis through the rim of a disk, parallel to the axis through its center, J=12MR2+MR2J = \tfrac12 MR^2 + MR^2.

Theorem 19.11 (Dynamics of a solid about a fixed axis)

For a solid rotating about a fixed axis Δ\Delta in an inertial frame,

JΔθ¨=MΔ(Fext), ⁣d ⁣dt(12JΔθ˙2)=MΔ(Fext)θ˙:J_\Delta\,\ddot\theta = \sum\mathcal M_\Delta(\vect F_{\mathrm{ext}}), \qquad \frac{\dd}{\dd t}\Big(\tfrac12 J_\Delta\dot\theta^2\Big) = \sum\mathcal M_\Delta(\vect F_{\mathrm{ext}})\,\dot\theta :

the moments of the external forces about the axis drive the angular acceleration, and a moment MΔ\mathcal M_\Delta delivers the power MΔω\mathcal M_\Delta\omega. An ideal pivot (frictionless bearing) exerts no moment about its axis and so neither accelerates nor brakes the rotation.

Proof. Theorem 15.8 projected on Δ\Delta, with LΔ=JΔθ˙L_\Delta = J_\Delta\dot\theta and JΔJ_\Delta constant for a rigid body; multiply by θ˙\dot\theta for the energy form (the internal forces of a rigid body do no work: the distances do not change).

Example 19.12 (Compound pendulum; torsion pendulum)

A solid of mass MM pivoting about a horizontal axis at distance dd from GG: the weight’s moment is Mgdsinθ-Mgd\sin\theta, so JΔθ¨=MgdsinθJ_\Delta\ddot\theta = -Mgd\sin\theta and small swings have the period

T=2πJΔMgd,T = 2\pi\sqrt{\frac{J_\Delta}{Mgd}} ,

that of a simple pendulum of length JΔ/MdJ_\Delta/Md — for a uniform rod pivoted at one end, 2L/32L/3. A disk hung from a wire of torsion constant CC (restoring moment Cθ-C\theta): Jθ¨=CθJ\ddot\theta = -C\theta, T=2πJ/CT = 2\pi\sqrt{J/C} — the torsion balance that measured GG and Coulomb’s law.

Three solids in motion: a compound pendulum swinging about a pivot (moment of the weight about the axis), a torsion pendulum (moment of the wire), and a solid rolling without slipping down an incline — the larger its J/MR2, the slower it rolls.
Three solids in motion: a compound pendulum swinging about a pivot (moment of the weight about the axis), a torsion pendulum (moment of the wire), and a solid rolling without slipping down an incline — the larger its J/MR2J/MR^2, the slower it rolls.

Proposition 19.13 (Rolling without slipping down an incline)

A solid of revolution (J=kMR2J = kMR^2 about its axis) released on an incline of angle α\alpha rolls without slipping with the acceleration

a=gsinα1+k:a = \frac{g\sin\alpha}{1 + k} :

57gsinα\tfrac57 g\sin\alpha for a solid sphere, 23gsinα\tfrac23 g\sin\alpha for a disk, 12gsinα\tfrac12 g\sin\alpha for a hoop — independent of mass and radius.

Proof. Energy: Mgh=12Mv2(1+k)Mgh = \tfrac12 Mv^2(1 + k) along the slope (the static friction at the resting contact point does no work), so v2=2ahv^2 = 2ah with aa as stated; or Newton for GG and the moment theorem about GG with the friction ff: Ma=MgsinαfMa = Mg\sin\alpha - f, kMR2ω˙=fRkMR^2\dot\omega = fR, a=Rω˙a = R\dot\omega.

Remark 19.14 (Deformable systems)

For a system that is not rigid, the kinetic energy theorem reads ΔEk=Wext+Wint\Delta E_k = W_{\mathrm{ext}} + W_{\mathrm{int}}: the internal forces do work (muscles, springs, friction inside the system). The skater pulling her arms in, the diver tucking, a cyclist standing on the pedals all gain kinetic energy with no external work — the center of mass theorem stays true, the energy comes from inside.

19.5 Exercises

Exercise 19.1

Masses 2.0kg2.0\,\mathrm{kg} at x=0x = 0 and 3.0kg3.0\,\mathrm{kg} at x=1.0mx = 1.0\,\mathrm{m}: position of GG. The Earth–Moon system (81:181:1, 384000km384\,000\,\mathrm{km}): distance of GG from the Earth’s center; compare with the Earth’s radius.

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.1.

xG=(2.0×0+3.0×1.0)/5.0=0.60mx_G = (2.0 \times 0 + 3.0 \times 1.0)/5.0 = 0.60\,\mathrm{m}. Earth–Moon: 384000/82=4700km384000/82 = 4700\,\mathrm{km} from the Earth’s center, inside the Earth (6370km6370\,\mathrm{km}): the Earth wobbles about a point 1700km1700\,\mathrm{km} below its surface.

Exercise 19.2

A 4.0kg4.0\,\mathrm{kg} rifle fires a 10g10\,\mathrm{g} bullet at 800m/s800\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}. Recoil speed; kinetic energies of bullet and rifle; where did the energy come from?

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.2.

4.0v=0.010×8004.0v = 0.010 \times 800: v=2.0m/sv = 2.0\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}. Bullet 12×0.010×8002=3.2kJ\tfrac12 \times 0.010 \times 800^2 = 3.2\,\mathrm{kJ}, rifle 8J8\,\mathrm{J}: from the powder’s chemical energy; the light body takes almost all of it (Ek=p2/2mE_k = p^2/2m with equal pp).

Exercise 19.3

A 1000kg1000\,\mathrm{kg} car at 20m/s20\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s} hits a 1500kg1500\,\mathrm{kg} car at rest; they lock together. Common speed; fraction of kinetic energy lost.

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.3.

v=20000/2500=8.0m/sv = 20000/2500 = 8.0\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}; EkE_k: 200kJ200\,\mathrm{kJ} before, 12×2500×64=80kJ\tfrac12 \times 2500 \times 64 = 80\,\mathrm{kJ} after: 60%60\% lost.

Exercise 19.4

Derive the moment of inertia of a uniform rod of mass MM, length LL, about a perpendicular axis through its end, then through its center; check Huygens’ theorem between the two.

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.4.

End: 0Lx2(M/L) ⁣dx=ML2/3\int_0^L x^2(M/L)\dd x = ML^2/3; center: L/2L/2x2(M/L) ⁣dx=ML2/12\int_{-L/2}^{L/2}x^2(M/L) \dd x = ML^2/12; Huygens with d=L/2d = L/2: ML2/12+ML2/4=ML2/3ML^2/12 + ML^2/4 = ML^2/3.

Exercise 19.5 ★★

Kinetic energy of a rolling uniform cylinder and of a rolling hoop of the same mass and speed, as multiples of 12Mv2\tfrac12 Mv^2. Which stops first on a rough flat floor, and which climbs higher up a slope?

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.5.

Ek=12Mv2(1+k)E_k = \tfrac12 Mv^2(1 + k): cylinder 1.51.5, hoop 22 times 12Mv2\tfrac12 Mv^2. Same speed, more energy for the hoop: it rolls farther on a flat floor (same friction) and climbs higher (h=v2(1+k)/2gh = v^2(1 + k)/2g).

Exercise 19.6 ★★

Reduced mass of HCl (mCl=35mHm_{Cl} = 35m_H) and of the hydrogen atom (mp=1836mem_p = 1836m_e); relative correction to a vibration or orbital frequency computed with the light mass alone.

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.6.

HCl: μ=35mH/36=0.972mH\mu = 35m_H/36 = 0.972m_H; atom: μ=me/(1+1/1836)=0.99946me\mu = m_e/(1 + 1/1836) = 0.99946m_e. Frequencies 1/μ\propto 1/\sqrt\mu: +1.4%+1.4\% for HCl, +0.027%+0.027\% for hydrogen (the isotope shift between H and D spectra rests on it).

Exercise 19.7 ★★

A uniform rod of length 1.0m1.0\,\mathrm{m} pivots freely about one end. Period of small oscillations; length of the simple pendulum with the same period; the point of the rod (the center of percussion) where a sharp blow produces no reaction at the pivot is at that distance — why does a batter look for it?

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.7.

J=ML2/3J = ML^2/3, d=L/2d = L/2: T=2π(ML2/3)/(MgL/2)=2π2L/3g=1.64sT = 2\pi\sqrt{(ML^2/3)/(MgL/2)} = 2\pi\sqrt{2L/3g} = 1.64\,\mathrm{s}; equivalent length 2L/3=0.67m2L/3 = 0.67\,\mathrm{m}. A blow at the center of percussion sets the rod rotating about the pivot with no impulsive reaction there: hit the ball at the bat’s “sweet spot” and the hands feel no sting.

Exercise 19.8 ★★

A disk (M=0.20kgM = 0.20\,\mathrm{kg}, R=10cmR = 10\,\mathrm{cm}) hangs from a wire and oscillates in torsion with a 2.0s2.0\,\mathrm{s} period. Torsion constant of the wire.

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.8.

J=12MR2=1.0×103kgm2J = \tfrac12 MR^2 = 1.0 \times 10^{-3}\,\mathrm{kg}\,\mathrm{m}^{2}; C=4π2J/T2=9.9×103Nm/radC = 4\pi^2J/T^2 = 9.9 \times 10^{-3}\,\mathrm{N}\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{rad}.

Exercise 19.9 ★★

A flywheel of moment of inertia 10kgm210\,\mathrm{kg}\,\mathrm{m}^{2} spins at 3000rpm3000\,\mathrm{rpm}. Stored energy; braking moment that stops it in 10s10\,\mathrm{s}; number of turns during the braking.

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.9.

ω=314rad/s\omega = 314\,\mathrm{rad}/\mathrm{s}, E=12Jω2=4.9×105JE = \tfrac12 J\omega^2 = 4.9 \times 10^{5}\,\mathrm{J}; Γ=Jω/t=314Nm\Gamma = J\omega/t = 314\,\mathrm{N}\,\mathrm{m}; turns: 12ωt/2π=250\tfrac12\omega t/2\pi = 250.

Exercise 19.10 ★★★

A solid sphere, a solid cylinder and a hoop are released together at the top of an incline. Order of arrival, and the ratio of their accelerations. Does the result depend on their radii or masses?

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.10.

a=gsinα/(1+k)a = g\sin\alpha/(1 + k): sphere (k=2/5k = 2/5) 0.7140.714, cylinder (1/21/2) 0.6670.667, hoop (11) 0.5000.500 times gsinαg\sin\alpha: sphere first, hoop last; no mass or radius anywhere.

Exercise 19.11 ★★★

Ballistic pendulum: a 10g10\,\mathrm{g} bullet at 400m/s400\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s} embeds in a 2.0kg2.0\,\mathrm{kg} block hanging from a 1.0m1.0\,\mathrm{m} string. Speed just after impact; height reached; fraction of the bullet’s kinetic energy lost. Why can one not use energy conservation for the impact itself?

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.11.

Momentum: 0.010×400=2.01v0.010 \times 400 = 2.01\,v: v=2.0m/sv = 2.0\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}; then energy: h=v2/2g=0.20mh = v^2/2g = 0.20\,\mathrm{m}. EkE_k: 800J800\,\mathrm{J} before, 12×2.01×4.0=4.0J\tfrac12 \times 2.01 \times 4.0 = 4.0\,\mathrm{J} after: 99.5%99.5\% lost to deformation and heat. The impact is inelastic — energy is not conserved through it, momentum is (the string’s tension is vertical and the impact brief).

Exercise 19.12 ★★★

Elastic head-on collision of m1m_1 at v1v_1 with m2m_2 at rest: derive v1=m1m2m1+m2v1v_1' = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}v_1 and v2=2m1m1+m2v1v_2' = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}v_1. Fraction of energy transferred when a neutron hits a proton; a carbon nucleus (12mn12m_n); a lead nucleus (207mn207m_n). Why are reactors moderated with light nuclei?

Solution

Solution of Exercise 19.12.

m1v1=m1v1+m2v2m_1v_1 = m_1v_1' + m_2v_2' and m1v12=m1v12+m2v22m_1v_1^2 = m_1v_1'^2 + m_2v_2'^2 give v1+v1=v2v_1 + v_1' = v_2' (divide the energy equation by the momentum one), whence the formulas. Energy fraction to the target 4m1m2/(m1+m2)24m_1m_2/(m_1 + m_2)^2: proton 100%100\%; carbon 4×12/169=28%4 \times 12/169 = 28\%; lead 4×207/2082=1.9%4 \times 207/208^2 = 1.9\%. Light nuclei take the neutron’s energy in a few collisions (water, graphite); lead would need hundreds.

A yo-yo unwinding: the centre of mass falls, the disk spins, and the string’s tension is what ties the two motions together — the weekend problem.
A yo-yo unwinding: the centre of mass falls, the disk spins, and the string’s tension is what ties the two motions together — the weekend problem.

19.6 Problem: The yo-yo

Problem 19.1

Weekend problem — a disk on a thin axle at the end of a string: why it falls so slowly, how fast it spins at the bottom, why it “sleeps” there, and which way a spool rolls when you pull its thread

A yo-yo is a uniform disk of mass M=50gM = 50\,\mathrm{g} and radius R=3.0cmR = 3.0\,\mathrm{cm} with a thin axle of radius r=0.40cmr = 0.40\,\mathrm{cm} around which a string of length h=1.0mh = 1.0\,\mathrm{m} is wound; the string’s upper end is held fixed. g=9.81m/s2g = 9.81\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}^{2}; J=12MR2J = \tfrac12 MR^2 about the axis.

Part I — Kinematics and energy.

  1. Where is the center of mass GG of the yo-yo? Why?
  2. Show from Koenig’s theorem that its kinetic energy is 12MvG2+12Jω2\tfrac12 Mv_G^2 + \tfrac12 J\omega^2.
  3. Derive J=12MR2J = \tfrac12 MR^2 by integrating over rings, and compute JJ.
  4. As the string unwinds without slipping from the axle, relate vGv_G and ω\omega.
  5. Deduce Ek=12MvG2(1+R2/2r2)E_k = \tfrac12 Mv_G^2(1 + R^2/2r^2) and compute the factor in parentheses. Comment.

Part II — The fall.

  1. Forces on the yo-yo; write the center-of-mass theorem (vertical axis downward).
  2. Write the angular momentum theorem about the axis through GG (which forces have a moment?).
  3. Combine with question 4 to find the acceleration aG=g/(1+R2/2r2)a_G = g/(1 + R^2/2r^2); compute it.
  4. Compute the string tension and compare with the weight.
  5. Time to unwind the 1.0m1.0\,\mathrm{m} of string, and the speed then; compare with a stone dropped from the same height.
  6. Angular velocity at the bottom, in rad/s and turns per minute.
  7. Split the kinetic energy at the bottom into its translational and rotational parts.
  8. Check the energy balance: compare MghMgh with the kinetic energy at the bottom, and say why the string’s tension, though large, does no work.

Part III — At the bottom: the sleeper. When the string is fully unwound it stops the center of mass in a few milliseconds; the yo-yo keeps spinning in the loop at the end of the string (“sleeping”).

  1. Why does the spin survive the stop of GG? (Which theorem, and which force would have been needed to stop it?)
  2. Estimate the average tension during the stop if GG is halted over 5ms5\,\mathrm{ms}.
  3. The loop rubs on the axle with a friction moment Γ=1.0×104Nm\Gamma = 1.0 \times 10^{-4}\,\mathrm{N}\,\mathrm{m}: how long does the yo-yo sleep?
  4. A sharp upward jerk on the string makes the string grip the axle again; the spinning yo-yo then climbs. Using energy, to what height could it rise if nothing were lost? Why, in practice, less?
  5. During the climb, is the tension larger or smaller than the weight? (Sign of aGa_G.)
  6. What would happen with a yo-yo whose axle radius equalled RR (string wound on the rim)? Compute its fall acceleration.

Part IV — The spool on the table. The same object lies on a rough table, axle horizontal, and its string leaves the bottom of the axle horizontally; one pulls with a force FF. It rolls without slipping.

  1. At the contact point CC with the table, what is the velocity of the spool’s material? Deduce that the motion is, at each instant, a rotation about CC.
  2. Compute the moment of FF about CC (lever arm RrR - r) and that of the weight and of the table’s reaction.
  3. Using the angular momentum theorem about CC with JC=J+MR2J_C = J + MR^2 (Huygens), find aGa_G and show the spool rolls toward the hand.
  4. Now the string is pulled at an angle β\beta above the horizontal. Show that the spool does not roll when the line of action of FF passes through CC, i.e. cosβ=r/R\cos\beta = r/R, and rolls away from the hand for steeper pulls. Compute that angle.
  5. Compute aGa_G for F=0.20NF = 0.20\,\mathrm{N} pulled horizontally, and the friction force needed; what limits FF before the spool slips?
  6. Summarize: the three theorems used (center of mass, angular momentum about an axis, energy) and what each decided.
Solution

Solution of Problem 19.1.

1. On the axis, at the center of the disk, by symmetry.

2. Koenig: Ek=12MvG2+EkE_k = \tfrac12 Mv_G^2 + E_k^*, and in the barycentric frame the yo-yo rotates about its axis: Ek=12Jω2E_k^* = \tfrac12 J\omega^2.

3. Ring of radius ρ\rho, mass 2Mρ ⁣dρ/R22M\rho\,\dd\rho/R^2: J=0Rρ22Mρ ⁣dρ/R2=MR2/2=0.5×0.050×9×104=2.25×105kgm2J = \int_0^R \rho^2\cdot 2M\rho\,\dd\rho/R^2 = MR^2/2 = 0.5 \times 0.050 \times 9\times10^{-4} = 2.25 \times 10^{-5}\,\mathrm{kg}\,\mathrm{m}^{2}.

4. The string is fixed and unwinds from the axle: the point of the axle in contact with it is momentarily at rest, so vG=rωv_G = r\omega.

5. Ek=12MvG2+12(12MR2)(vG/r)2=12MvG2(1+R2/2r2)E_k = \tfrac12 Mv_G^2 + \tfrac12(\tfrac12 MR^2)(v_G/r)^2 = \tfrac12 Mv_G^2(1 + R^2/2r^2); R2/2r2=9/(2×0.16)=28R^2/2r^2 = 9/(2 \times 0.16) = 28: factor 2929 — almost all the energy is in the spin.

6. Weight MgMg downward, tension TT upward: MaG=MgTMa_G = Mg - T.

7. Only the tension has a moment about the axis (lever arm rr): Jω˙=TrJ\dot\omega = Tr.

8. ω˙=aG/r\dot\omega = a_G/r: T=JaG/r2=(R2/2r2)MaGT = Ja_G/r^2 = (R^2/2r^2)Ma_G; then MaG=Mg(R2/2r2)MaGMa_G = Mg - (R^2/2r^2)Ma_G, aG=g/29=0.34m/s2a_G = g/29 = 0.34\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}^{2}.

9. T=M(gaG)=0.050×9.47=0.47NT = M(g - a_G) = 0.050 \times 9.47 = 0.47\,\mathrm{N}, 97%97\% of the weight: the string nearly holds it.

10. t=2h/aG=2.4st = \sqrt{2h/a_G} = 2.4\,\mathrm{s}; vG=aGt=0.82m/sv_G = a_Gt = 0.82\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}. A stone: 0.45s0.45\,\mathrm{s} and 4.4m/s4.4\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}.

11. ω=vG/r=205rad/s=1960rpm\omega = v_G/r = 205\,\mathrm{rad}/\mathrm{s} = 1960\,\mathrm{rpm}.

12. 12MvG2=0.017J\tfrac12 Mv_G^2 = 0.017\,\mathrm{J} against 12Jω2=0.47J\tfrac12 J\omega^2 = 0.47\,\mathrm{J}: 2828 times more energy in the spin than in the fall.

13. Mgh=0.49JMgh = 0.49\,\mathrm{J}; 12MvG2×29=0.5×0.050×0.67×29=0.49J\tfrac12 Mv_G^2 \times 29 = 0.5 \times 0.050 \times 0.67 \times 29 = 0.49\,\mathrm{J}. The tension acts at the point of the string that is at rest (the string does not move): zero power.

14. The stopping force acts along the string, through the axis: no moment about it; the angular momentum JωJ\omega is untouched. Only a tangential force (friction on the axle) could slow the spin.

15. TMvG/Δt+Mg=0.050×0.82/0.005+0.49=8.7NT \approx Mv_G/\Delta t + Mg = 0.050 \times 0.82/0.005 + 0.49 = 8.7\,\mathrm{N}, eighteen times the weight — hence the jerk felt by the finger.

16. Jω˙=ΓJ\dot\omega = -\Gamma: t=Jω/Γ=2.25×105×205/104=46st = J\omega/\Gamma = 2.25\times10^{-5} \times 205/10^{-4} = 46\,\mathrm{s}.

17. All the spin energy 12Jω2=0.47J\tfrac12 J\omega^2 = 0.47\,\mathrm{J} converts to MghMgh': h=0.96mh' = 0.96\,\mathrm{m}, nearly the full height; less in practice because of the axle friction during the sleep and the losses in the jerk.

18. aGa_G is downward (the yo-yo decelerates on the way up) while vGv_G is upward: T=M(gaG)<MgT = M(g - a_G) < Mg — smaller than the weight.

19. r=Rr = R: factor 1+1/2=1.51 + 1/2 = 1.5, aG=2g/3=6.5m/s2a_G = 2g/3 = 6.5\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}^{2} — a fast drop, little spin: a thin axle is what makes a yo-yo.

20. Rolling without slipping: the material point at CC has zero velocity; the velocity field of a rigid body with one point at rest is a rotation about that point (axis through CC, same ω\omega).

21. FF acts at the bottom of the axle, a height RrR - r above the table, horizontally toward the hand: moment F(Rr)F(R - r) about CC in the sense that rolls the spool toward the hand; the weight and the reaction pass through CC (no moment).

22. (J+MR2)ω˙=F(Rr)(J + MR^2)\dot\omega = F(R - r), aG=Rω˙=FR(Rr)/(32MR2)=2F(Rr)/3MR>0a_G = R\dot\omega = FR(R - r)/ (\tfrac32 MR^2) = 2F(R - r)/3MR > 0: toward the hand.

23. The line of action of FF passes through CC when the string from the bottom of the axle meets the table at CC: cosβ=r/R\cos\beta = r/R, β=82\beta = 82^\circ. Steeper: the moment about CC reverses, the spool rolls away (and for β\beta large enough lifts).

24. aG=2×0.20×0.026/(3×0.050×0.030)=2.3m/s2a_G = 2 \times 0.20 \times 0.026/(3 \times 0.050 \times 0.030) = 2.3\,\mathrm{m}/\mathrm{s}^{2}; friction from MaG=FfMa_G = F - f (friction opposes FF): f=0.200.050×2.3=0.085Nf = 0.20 - 0.050 \times 2.3 = 0.085\,\mathrm{N}; it must stay below μsMg0.2N\mu_sMg \approx 0.2\,\mathrm{N} (for μs=0.4\mu_s = 0.4), i.e. F0.5NF \lesssim 0.5\,\mathrm{N}.

25. Center of mass: the translation of GG and the tension; angular momentum about an axis: the spin and the rolling direction; energy: the speed at the bottom and the height of the climb.

Terms defined in this chapter

See all 393 terms in the glossary